“Popes and Bankers” Book Review
April 22nd, 2010I just finished reading Popes and Bankers: A Cultural History of Credit and Debt, from Aristotle to AIG by Jack Cashill, so I guess it’s time to post the review.
Popes and Bankers is an incredibly fascinating read. And just like the title infers, it’s a cultural history of credit and debt. It caught my eye because of the recent credit and banking crisis that has tanked the U.S. economy. Popes and Bankers attempts to explain how we ended up in this crisis by exploring society’s views on usury (a.k.a. lending at interest) throughout world history. Cashill also discusses the people that had major impacts on our views of moneylending - the authors, the philosophers, the rulers, the businessmen, the crooks, etc… Interestingly, the book is written from a Christian worldview. So a lot of time is spent exploring and commenting on the Jewish and Christian influence on society.
The list of interesting topics is too long to list… But, for me, there were a few key things that really made the book worth reading. First was reading how Charles Ponzi got a scheme named after him. (Very timely, I know.) Second was learning about all the bubbles and financial meltdowns of different societies throughout the centuries.
Third… I’ve always heard the anti-semitic comments about “jewish bankers”, but I’ve never really understood where these thoughts come from. Interestingly, they partially go back to Mosaic law which allowed the Jews to lend money at interest to strangers. And Shakespeare’s The Merchant of Venice didn’t help either.
Fourth, it seems that all financial troubles generally result from greed - either people wanting more than they have or people trying to make money without doing anything of tangible value. And lastly, I found it interesting how our unique American culture and politics brought about this recent collapse.
There were also a few things that I didn’t like about Popes and Bankers. I have a bachelor’s degree in engineering, a master’s degree in business, and I usually win at Scrabble, but I found the first few chapters nearly incomprehensible. I didn’t know half of the words that Cashill used, and I really felt like he was trying to compete with Virgil and Shakespeare while crafting his prose. Fortunately, what I did understand was interesting and I pressed on. Once you get over that mountain, the rest of the book is very readable although there are still quite a few post-doctoral words to be found.
Legal stuff: I received this book free from Thomas Nelson Publishers as part of their BookSneeze.com book review bloggers program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
